Well me and a couple friends have narrowed it down to the face plate gets loose and allows light to get it, but I'm not talking about that^ face, I'm talking about this face coming loose and allowing light through.
You can see the little lights are separate from the main cluster of light for the RPM and MPH, if you get this^ far, take a look at the backside of the plate you just removed to get to this^ point and you should see that for the engine light there is a separate piece of paper there, my guess is it has come loose, take it apart and see if it need to be glued back on.
If ya need help taking it apart let me now I've done a couple of these in my time.