Ford Forums banner

1 - 20 of 28 Posts

·
feed me hey
Joined
·
4,692 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Ever since converting to manual I was always sure my car had lost low end torque. I had gutted the cats at the same time and thought that was the cause. New (and better) cats didnt solve the problem so it somewhat left me stumped... untill tonite.

I had always beleived that the EA - EB1 auto's and up to ED V8's (unsure about EF and EL but I suspect it would be the same) were able to use the original Auto version of the engine ECU when converted to manual.

This is true for the 6cyl but not the V8's.

Basically the V8 have an operating mode where in reverse gear they run a torque limiting mode to protect the reverse gear. There is a link from the auto trans ecu to the engine ecu dedicated for this mode.

The problem when changing to manual and there fore removing the auto trans ecu is that the engine ecu no longer receives the signal. This poses a problem. Here is a peice copied directly from the Ford Factory Workshop Manual: Section 7-2-70

Default Engine Operating Modes
7B:Reverse Gear Indication
Engine Controller, EEC-IV will assume torque cut off mode in all gears. However when the calculated engine-to-road speed ratio is outside the range of the reverse gear, toque cut off is ignored. If a fault is undetected, a reduction in power may be percived in lower forward gears and shifts may be firm
So obviously the firm shifts won't apply to the manual but the lack of power will. It will be evident throughout first gear and at the start of 2nd I think. This is the exact reason why I have felt my 2nd gear was quicker than 1st to accelerate. It also explains why it doesnt show up that well on the dyno. Basically when its in 3rd gear its only at really low RPM that it will be in the torque limiting mode. There is no EEC fault code for the missing signal

The connection is between pin 3 on the 95LE trans ECU and goes to pin 5 on the engine ECU. Looking at the chart with the different states of the various outputs and inputs the Transmission Communication Link gives the EEC a 25hz or 50hz signal depending on the state (reverse or not). So that makes things harder because it isn't as simple as using a resistor and feeding pin 5 with the correct voltage.

A friend of mine who is pretty clued up with Falcon's has a couple of EB1 V8 ECU's and we are going to retrofit one into my car. We will have to wire in a BAP sensor and also rewire the WAC relay for the air conditioning. This will also mean I will lose the recirculation override feature of the air con system.
 

·
i pity tha fool
Joined
·
1,040 Posts
i'm sure thats something alot of folk dont know about!

the dudes who did my conversion said i had manual ECU.. since they did a top notch jon i beleived em. however, how can i double check??
 

·
feed me hey
Joined
·
4,692 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Get the part number off it. Im going to bed now but If someone already hasn't checked it ill post the various part numbers of the ECU's.
Im so wrapped with this. Maybe now I will beable to beat my previous auto transmission 1/4 mile times

15.95 with auto and 3.27 diff
15.96 with manual and 3.45 diff. The car was sucking hot air from the engine bay but it still goes to show the diffeence.
 

·
feed me hey
Joined
·
4,692 Posts
Discussion Starter #6 (Edited)
Manual 5.0 ECU part numbers:

91DA 12A650 DX
91DA 12A650 FX

Both of these can be smartlock or non smartlock. And both can be EB1 or EB2/ED. X can be any letter but I assume the later letter would suggest perhaps what era ECU it is? Can anyone shed some light on this?

My problem is my car is EB2 but non smartlock. How many 5.0 manual cars were made in the period of 2/92 - 10/92. How many of those will be wrecked and have ECU's avalible? Hence the reason why we have to use the EB1 version (since we already have it).
 

·
do YOU have rubber?
Joined
·
2,357 Posts
I'm going to make this suggestions with the comment that I've not personally researched this scenario Karl, nor do i know much about the workings of the BTR transmission controller when there's no BTR in sight, but if the trans ECU behaves in a sane (by some stretch of the word sane) way when installed but disconnected from the transmission, couldn't you use your original ECU (and hence retain the features that the EB1 V8 ECU will rob you of) and reinstall the trans ECU so that it keeps it happy?

Failing that it may be easier to fabricate a 25 / 50 Hz (which ever is the one used to signify 1st gear) oscillator and feed that into the ECU.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
812 Posts
Hey NZ let me know how you go because I am running an auto computer in my car and also have similar symptons as you.

And also what would happen if you used a manual computer in a series 1 V8 auto.
 

·
feed me hey
Joined
·
4,692 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
9psi EB said:
NZ, you could use a small and quick $10 oscillator circuit to generate the 25 or 50hz frequency and see what the result is.
Its not a constant signal it varies apparently as in it seems to be a code of on and off's made up of the frequency. I don't know how else to explain it.
 

·
feed me hey
Joined
·
4,692 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
cogo_81 said:
Hey NZ let me know how you go because I am running an auto computer in my car and also have similar symptons as you.

And also what would happen if you used a manual computer in a series 1 V8 auto.
Will keep you updated.

As far as I know using a manual computer in an auto will possibly give stalling when decellerating but apart from that don't know.

The first thing I am going to do tommorrow is plug the ecu back in and see what happens. It can either work and ill be a happy chappy or it can see no transmission and go pear shaped. I don't think it will work as there is going to be no Shift Lever Position signal anyway so it may just send no signal to the EEC about being in reverse or not. If that happens we are going to do some trickery by working out the resistances of each transmission solenoid and fool the puter into thinking its in park It has to be done to each solenoid sa if theres one thats out it can throw other things out as well. It isnt as simple as using one resistor on the Shift Lever Position pin as the combination of solinoids being used have to match up with the gear position. Basically if the combination is wrong (if there were no resistors on each solinoid pin) then that will cause numerous fault codes and possibly send things into a spin.

Starting to get confusing but the guy who's helping me knows his stuff and has done it to a few race cars.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
262 Posts
If you are after a manual ECU to suit your car or any other electronic part for your car give these guys a call. It will save you heaps of time tracking a manual ECU at the wreckers. It's bloody hard to find a ford 6 cylinder manual at the wreckers and a V8 is just about imposible. Here is the link to their web page and their phone numbers... They have distributors all over australia i think.

Automotive EMF

http://www.autoemf.com.au


Phone: (07) 3000-4000
Phone: (07) 3000-7232
Phone: (07) 3000-7231
Fax: (07) 3000-7128
 

·
Lamahs approve of manuals
Joined
·
1,382 Posts
NZ,

Not sure what other inputs the trans gives to the ECU (but I guess you can find out since it sounds like you have the WS manual), but its not possible to simply plug in the Gear selector switch (it was a smallish box in the 97LE) back into the remaining auto loom, set it at the appropriate gear (1st I guess), and then secure it somewhere ?

Like ignition suggested, it might be easier to kludge some sensors / inputs back into onto the auto transmission loom, than fiddle with smartlock and other ECU's.

Just for interests sake, the EL manual computer plugged in and worked 1st go with on the EL - BUT I can no longer get the car into the idle self test mode :fraz: Not sure if this is related, or something else thats freaked out since I last checked timing... (will experiment this arvo - weather permitting).

At least you've managed to nail down your problems to a specific cause though (unlike myself, who is still floundering around :p ). Let us know how it progresses...
 

·
Lamahs approve of manuals
Joined
·
1,382 Posts
cogo_81 said:
holy crap man, thats like the holy grail :)
If your talking about that EMF site . . then yes, it looks like the holy grail.
Basically all Falcon ECU's are $350 . . . AMAZING !

(sux to own a probe tho - at $1650 for a new ecu).

More FF members should know about this place (especially ppl doing manual conversions)... I got lucky getting a manual ecu, otherwise I would have been in the crapper :p
 

·
feed me hey
Joined
·
4,692 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
Ill have the appropriate values and instructions on how to set up the resistors tommorrow. My friend had them at his place but of course the computer wouldnt boot up for some reason. He's got it on his computer at ford so he'll send it to me tommorrow. If I can get away with using the auto puter itll cost a whole lot less.
 
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
Top